The Evolution of Cryptocurrency: A Path to Maturity

Maturing Crypto Markets

Cryptocurrency markets, long perceived as the financial Wild West, are beginning to mature. This evolution is driven by firmer regulation, greater acceptance of existing rules, and innovative market mechanisms enhancing price efficiency and liquidity. As Mariia Petryk highlights in her article, these changes are making crypto-assets, like Bitcoin, safer investments.

SEC Approval of Bitcoin ETFs

A significant milestone was reached in January when the SEC approved spot trading on exchanges of funds invested in Bitcoin. These Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) allow ordinary investors to trade Bitcoin without direct custody risks. By reflecting Bitcoin's dollar price, ETF shares offer a more accessible and secure investment pathway, signaling the crypto sector’s move toward the financial mainstream.

Regulatory Challenges

Despite this progress, major roadblocks remain, notably the absence of specific federal cryptocurrency regulations in the United States. Without clear rules to distinguish between fraudulent actors and legitimate players, some investors may still view the crypto market with skepticism.

Addressing Regulatory Gaps

Nevertheless, regulatory gaps are being addressed. Several U.S. states require crypto entities to obtain licenses for local transactions. Federal agencies like the SEC and the Department of Justice heavily police the sector. Additionally, the crypto industry is taking steps to self-regulate. Some exchanges have registered as Money Service Businesses with the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN), complying with the U.S. Bank Secrecy Act to signal their commitment to security and transparency.

Evidence of Market Maturation

These self-regulation efforts are more than mere public relations stunts. They are tangible indicators of the market's maturation. Research, including a recent paper for the Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis (Nimalendran et al., 2021) and an article in the Harvard Business Review (Petryk, 2024), shows that market efficiency—a key measure of how well asset prices reflect new information—has improved in crypto markets with greater regulatory oversight.

Importance of Market Efficiency

Market efficiency is crucial because it levels the playing field for all investors. Efficient markets prevent better-informed traders from exploiting uninformed ones, ensuring fairer trading conditions. Researchers traditionally measure efficiency using variance ratios (VR), which indicate the predictability of price movements. More efficient markets yield VRs closer to 1, showing that new information is quickly priced in.

Comparing Different Crypto Asset Classes

The research compared the efficiency of different crypto asset classes. Initial coin offerings (ICOs) remain largely unregulated, mirroring the chaotic early days of crypto. Initial exchange offerings (IEOs), launched by crypto exchanges, offer a layer of due diligence through soft regulation. Leading exchanges like Kraken and Coinbase have obtained Money Service Business licenses from FinCEN, adhering to anti-money laundering regulations.

Efficiency of IDOs vs. IEOs

Initial decentralized exchange offerings (IDOs), on the other hand, use blockchain technology to raise funds directly from investors. While IDOs automate trading to reduce frictions, they remain unregulated, prompting a comparison with IEOs. Analysis of 174 crypto-assets issued between January 2021 and December 2022 revealed that FinCEN-compliant IEOs were as efficient as traditional initial public offerings (IPOs). Though IDOs were slightly more efficient in the short term, this advantage diminished over time, underscoring the enduring benefits of regulation.

A Path Toward Mainstream Adoption

From an investor’s perspective, not all cryptocurrencies are equal. Vehicles that comply with third-party regulations indicate the sector's maturation and its efforts to inspire investor confidence. Despite the absence of federal regulations, the crypto industry is moving beyond the ICO mania of 2017-2018. As investors become savvier, they can better identify high-quality projects, and the industry is upping its game in response.


The crypto market is preparing for mainstream adoption at varying speeds. While political gridlock may delay tailored federal regulations, encouraging self-regulated compliance with frameworks like FinCEN's offers a practical workaround, fostering a safer and more reliable crypto investment environment.


The Author

Don Noble, a Partner at the Florida CFO Group and a technology expert, has an extensive background in financial leadership and advisory roles. With his wealth of experience, he helps businesses optimize their financial and technological strategies, fostering growth and resilience in today's dynamic marketplace. For more information, you can visit Don’s LinkedIn Profile for more information.

Contact Us

If you have any questions or would like to have a discussion about your organization's finance function, please give the Florida CFO Group a call at (877) 652-2367 or email us. We are here to help you navigate your financial challenges and achieve success.


Nimalendran, M., Pathak, P., Petryk, M., & Qiu, L. (2021). Informational Efficiency of Cryptocurrency Markets (SSRN Scholarly Paper 3818818).

Petryk, M. (2024, March 25). Is Crypto Cleaning Up Its Act? Harvard Business Review.



Share this post