Raising capital is not only about getting money. It is about making the right choice for your business, your cash flow, and your control.
Every growing business reaches a point when more capital is needed to expand, hire, or invest in new opportunities. When your business reaches that point, you will need to determine whether you fund that growth through debt or through equity.
This decision affects more than your financial statements. It determines how much control you keep, how much risk you take, and how much of your company you will still own in the future.
For many people, it's more of an emotional risk-tolerance decision than a financial one. This is not an easy decision, so a better understanding of the differences will help you make the best choice at the right time.
What Is Debt Financing?
As you know, debt means borrowing money that must be paid back with interest. You are using someone else’s money, typically a bank, to fund your growth while retaining full ownership of your business.
Advantages of Debt
- You stay in control of decisions.
- Payment terms are clear and predictable.
- You keep all future profits.
Disadvantages of Debt
- Payments continue even when revenue slows.
- Lenders often require guarantees or collateral.
- It can strain cash flow if growth takes longer than expected.
- Loan covenants can become an issue even when you are current on payments.
Here’s an example of how debt can impact a business:
Imagine a small manufacturing company that borrows one million dollars to purchase new equipment. Sales increase, but customers pay more slowly than expected.
The loan payments still come due every month. The new equipment helps them grow, but it also increases financial pressure until cash flow catches up.
What Is Equity Financing?
Financing with equity means bringing in investors who buy a piece of your business in exchange for cash. They share in profits and almost always want a say in how the company is managed. You do not have to make regular payments, but you give up ownership, and possibly, autonomy.
Advantages of Equity
- No loan payments or interest.
- Investors share the financial risk.
- You may gain experience or connections from investors.
Disadvantages of Equity
- You give up part of your company.
- Investors may expect decision-making power.
- If your company grows quickly, it can become far more expensive than debt.
Let’s consider this example of a company choosing equity financing:
Picture a technology startup that sells 20% of its ownership to raise capital for product development. The funding helps speed up growth, but when the company becomes highly profitable later, the founders realize that 20% of the business now represents millions in value they no longer own.
However, without the investors' money, their start-up may not have been able to grow; therefore losing out on millions of dollars in additional value. The 80% ownership is now worth more than 100% with the addition of the investors.
The Trade-Offs That Really Matter
How do you decide between debt and equity? Consider your business objectives. Here is a chart comparing each option under the four common decision points you should keep in mind.
Common Misconceptions
You may have heard, or been led to believe, one or more of the following statements about equity and debt. If so, you are not alone. These are very common misunderstandings. However, understanding the reality is key to making the right choice for you and your company.
- “Equity is free money.” Equity is NOT free. You are selling ownership that you may never get back.
- “Debt is too risky.” Debt can be a smart choice if your cash flow is reliable and the terms are manageable.
- “More capital solves every problem.” Not true. Capital should fuel growth, not cover inefficiency. In my experience, this is probably the biggest issue in receiving additional capital.
How to Decide What Is Right for You
I know it is hard to choose the right financing option; especially if you are considering funding for the first time or if you have had one of the options go wrong for you in the past. Here is a basic assessment you can use to help you choose between debt and equity.
Assess Cash Flow
- Is your revenue consistent and predictable? Debt may be a good fit.
- Is your income uncertain? Equity may offer greater flexibility.
Define Growth Goals
- Are you planning for sustainable business growth? Debt can help you grow while staying independent.
- Is your business in a high-growth period? Equity can provide faster access to larger capital.
Check Comfort with Risk
- How comfortable are you with fixed monthly payments? If this feels doable, then debt may work well for you.
- Would you rather share decision-making in exchange for flexibility? Consider going the equity route and bringing in investors.
Compare Long-Term Cost
- Calculate both scenarios. The value of a 20% ownership stake in a few years may outweigh the total interest cost of a loan today
Example: Debt vs. Equity — The One Million Dollar Decision
Suppose you need one million dollars to expand operations. Let’s consider your options:
- Option A: Debt. Borrow at eight percent interest for five years. The total cost is about $200,000 in interest, but you keep full ownership.
- Option B: Equity. Sell 20% of your company for $1 million at a $5 million valuation. If your company later grows to fifty million dollars, that same 20% is now worth ten million.
Both options can work. The better one depends on what matters most to you: control or flexibility. Which option feels more comfortable to you?
Hybrid Options to Consider
But wait, there’s more. As usual, there are never only two distinct options. If the criteria for debt or equity left you concerned, adjacent choices are available:
- Convertible Notes: Loans that can convert into equity later.
- Mezzanine Financing: A mix of loan and ownership features.
- Strategic Investors: Partners who provide both capital and business expertise.
These options add flexibility but also complexity, so careful planning is essential.
The Bottom Line
Debt gives you control and predictability, but it also adds financial pressure. The stress of owing money to someone else can significantly affect the emotional well-being of many business owners.
Equity gives you flexibility and shared risk but reduces your ownership. The key here is to make sure you choose the right investors. I have found that the less sophisticated the investor, the more they want to be involved. Choose investors who can provide good advice and resources in your industry, or who want to be truly passive.
Key Takeaway
Debt buys control. Equity buys flexibility. Both have a price. Choose the one that supports your strategy and lets you sleep better at night.
About the Author
Steven W. Weldon, MBA/CPA is a fractional CFO and strategic advisor specializing in driving growth, profitability, and operational strength for small- to mid-market companies. With a background across private equity, public corporations, and venture capital, he helps businesses simplify financial complexity and unlock their full potential.
Contact the Florida CFO Group
If you have any questions or would like to discuss your organization’s finance and strategic management needs, please call the Florida CFO Group at 1-877-352-2367 or send us a message. We are here to help you navigate your financial challenges and achieve success!